Fine-scale environmental variation in species distribution modelling: regression dilution, latent variables and neighbourly advice
Greg McInerny and Drew Purves
25 January 2011
- Developing the next-generation of species distribution modelling (SDM) requires solutions to a number of widely recognised problems. Here, we address the problem of uncertainty in predictor variables arising from fine-scale environmental variation.
- We explain how this uncertainty may cause scale-dependent ‘regression dilution’, elsewhere a well-understood statistical issue, and explain its consequences for SDM. We then demonstrate a simple, general correction for regression dilution based on Bayesian methods using latent variables. With this correction in place, unbiased estimates of species occupancy vs. the true environment can be retrieved from data on occupancy vs. measured environment, where measured environment is correlated with the true environment, but subject to substantial measurement error.
- We then show how applying our correction to multiple co-occurring species simultaneously increases the accuracy of parameter estimates for each species, as well as estimates for the true environment at each survey plot – a phenomenon we call ‘neighbourly advice’. With a sufficient number of species, the estimates of the true environment at each plot can become extremely accurate.
- Our correction for regression dilution could be integrated with models addressing other issues in SDM, e.g. biotic interactions and/or spatial dynamics. We suggest that Bayesian analysis, as employed here to address uncertainty in predictor variables, might offer a flexible toolbox for developing such next-generation species distribution models.
Raul Garcia-Valdes, Miguel A Zavala, Migueal B Araujo, and Drew W Purves. Chasing a moving target: projecting climate change-induced shifts in non-equilibrial tree species distributions, Journal of Ecology, British Ecological Society, January 2013.
Greg J. McInerny and Rampal S. Etienne. Ditch the niche – is the niche a useful concept in ecology or species distribution modelling?, Journal of Biogeography, 2012.
Glenn Marion, Greg J. McInerny, Jörn Pagel, Stephen Catterall, Alex R. Cook, Florian Hartig, and Robert B. O'Hara. Parameter and uncertainty estimation for process-oriented population and distribution models: data, statistics and the niche, Journal of Biogeography, 2012.
Cory Merow, Matthew J. Smith, Thomas C. Edwards, Antoine Guisan, Sean McMahon, Signe Normand, Wilfried Thuiller, Rafael O. Wuest, Niklaus E. Zimmerman, and Jane Elith. What do we gain from simplicity versus complexity in species distribution models? , Ecography, Wiley, August 2014.